• Welcome to Crosman Air Pistol Owners Forum.

P17 vs. 13xx What do you think?

Started by BillK, February 04, 2015, 03:52:26 AM

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

BillK

Got a competition going this month between 2 of the best affordable shooters.  Same targets & same rules to shoot & see which is the best.
Got a hunch...Shoot a bunch.... :D
West Michigan
Crosman Nitro Venom .22
Crosman 760 - 782 - 1077
Sheridan S S - H - E9
Benjamin NP pistol - Disco - Prod
MIC B1 .177
2300S - 2300T - 2400kt
1740 - 2240 - 2250 - 1760 - 2260 - 1701P
1322 - 1377
MK I & II

tomykay12

P17. the stock trigger on my 1377's is so bad it makes it difficult to shoot well. I'll get to that one day...

bgmcgee

Can I use this one it started out as a 1377 ;D

how to capture screen
No really, sounds like a good one. I don't have either but from what I've read the p-17 might have a leg up, but you never know.
"I've lost what's left of my right mind"

mudduck48

If I can put down my Daisy 499B for 5min, I might give it a go. Look at these targets! What a rifle!
We need to keep going and have fun doing it.

WildKata

Quote from: mudduck48 on February 05, 2015, 07:05:17 PM
If I can put down my Daisy 499B for 5min, I might give it a go. Look at these targets! What a rifle!

Technically not a rifle with no rifling :)
My 1st air rifle No 102 Model 36 Daisy Plymouth, Mich  Register No C0011400 Feb, 1956
Model 766, maybe 30 shots - do not like pumping
Sheriden SS Garage Sale plugged barrel
2400KT .22 "Poor man's P-rod"
4500 psi compressor project - 1st stage and motor on hand.
Waiting on my next "unearned" "benefit" check to buy more materiel.  Never mind that I paid into the raped trust fund for 48 years.
Working age Viet Nam vets excluded from vets jobs bill.  Me bitter? You Betcha!
1650 psi compressor project - idea 1/12/2015, see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LUn4wotjGKQ at 5 min for .22 & 8 min for .177

twigboy

Quote from: WildKata on February 05, 2015, 11:49:06 PM
Technically not a rifle with no rifling :)

muzzle loading smoothbore = musket  :)

RC1947

Quote from: bgmcgee on February 05, 2015, 06:51:49 PM
Can I use this one it started out as a 1377 ;D

how to capture screen
No really, sounds like a good one. I don't have either but from what I've read the p-17 might have a leg up, but you never know.

That's a fine looking shooter. :-* RC
2240
1377

crossliner

Mr. Barry our 13s look identical  :-* Both goodlooking like the owners  :D






Noah

I love my modified 1377, 1322 and 1325, but I have to admit a broken-in Beeman P17 was a GREAT, accurate shooter I sometimes wish didn't give away to a buddy. Please keep us posted  :-*
"Money is like fertilizer: When it's hoarded, it stinks. When spread around, cool stuff grows." John Densmore, drummer of The Doors

Crosman 1377, 1322, 1325, 1750, 2250 and 2540, Benjamin Steroid 392, IB QB78D, Avanti/Daisy 853, Slavia 634.

DavidS

I like my 1322, though my P17 is slightly more accurate out to about 15 meters.

The ones I will grab if I need to go in a hurry (ie tornado flies through town, or similar):
Crosman 101 (My Original).
Crosman 140 (Sears 126-19300).
Crosman 2289.
Daisy 953.
Crosman 1322.
Crosman 1389.

Pauly5

I remember taking my 1377 to the range and getting 3/4 inch groups at 25 yards with a red dot sight. It always surprises me how accurate it is, and doesn't seem to be pellet fussy. I do like weihrauch/Beeman though. The answer is to have multiples of both.  :-*

RC1947

Quote from: Pauly5 on February 08, 2015, 01:16:12 AM
I do like weihrauch/Beeman though. The answer is to have multiples of both.  :-*
That's the spirit! :-* RC
2240
1377

K.O.

Honestly for a single pump pistol I keep watching for a used Daisy 7xx series...
1322XLT(2100/13XX hybyid)750 fps @ 16 pumps w/CPHP 14.3g

MK1322(2240/13XX/MK177 hybrid) 805 fps at @ 22 pumps w/14.3g CPHP

about 5 more 13xxs
Two Daisy 953(# 31x Jan. 1985) & (Sept 2004)
2100b (with old style piston)
.25 Mrod (50fpe tune)
.177 BSA Buccaneer (on the way)